Renee Engeln, a psychologist and body image researcher at Northwestern University, discusses on An Epidemic of Beauty Sickness at TEDxUConn 2013. Here follows the full transcript of the TEDx Talk.
Right click to download the MP3 audio:
Renee Engeln – Psychologist at Northwestern University
So, today’s theme is the future. I’m going to talk about a growing epidemic and what we might do to stop it. But first I’m going to start in the past.
About 15 years ago, I was an eager, young, graduate student and I spent a lot of time teaching. I really liked my students, I got to know them very well, and the more I listened to my female students, the more I picked up on something troubling. These bright, talented, young women were spending alarming amounts of time thinking about, talking about, trying to modify their physical appearance. They wanted so much to feel beautiful.
Now, our perceptions of beauty are complicated. They have deep evolutionary roots. From a scientific perspective, beauty is not just desirable, but also rare. So, what’s struck me was not that these women wanted to feel beautiful, or that they didn’t all feel beautiful all the time. Instead, what’s struck me was that their quest for beauty seemed, at least at times, to overrule, to overwhelm every other goal or interest they had. These were young women just embarking on their adult lives and they were worried. They worried that they were too fat, they worried that their skin wasn’t clear, they worried that they were already, at the tender age of 20, getting wrinkles, they worried that they didn’t look like a Sports Illustrated swimsuit model or a Victoria’s Secret angel. They worried that they had cellulite, they worried that they weren’t a size 00, and I was worried about them.
So, I went to my grad school adviser and I said, “I got an idea, this is what I’m going to study, right, this is going to be my thing, and in particular I’m going to consider how images like this might be affecting women.”
And she said, “Mm, na, don’t bother. You don’t need to look at that,” she said, “because really, smart women, they know better. They know better than to be affected by things like media images.”
And I said, “Well, that’s an empirical question.”
So, based on the research I’ve conducted since then, I have to say she was kind of right. In some ways, women do know better. This is an advertisement I use in one of my studies, and I’m going to show you some responses from research participants.
So, women know that the images of women they see in the media are often unusually thin, possibly even eating disordered. They know the women they see in these images aren’t representative of the general population of women, they understand that they’re statistical outliers. And on top of that, women are very aware that in the real world nobody, nobody actually looks like this. So, that’s the good news, women do know better, they know about eating disorders, they know about Photoshop, that’s great.
Here’s the bad news, it doesn’t help, it doesn’t seem to matter. Knowing better isn’t enough. The same woman who said this, for example, “This body type is unrealistically skinny, and her ribs are showing,” and you’re kind of like: yeah, right on. She followed it up with, “I’m not as skinny. Should I go to drastic weight-loss programs and tan, risking my health? I feel like I want to be like that, I wish I was a model. Maybe after seeing this picture, I won’t want to eat.” That’s not what you want here as a researcher, using this picture, I have to tell you, but we moved on.
This is not a failure of information processing, it’s not a failure of intelligence, and it is definitely not a failure to know better. This is beauty sickness, and that’s what I’m going to talk about today.
Category: Life & Style