This household told us that they wanted to build a pit that would last them a generation. So I asked them, “Why do you need a pit that lasts a generation? I mean, can’t you just build something that’s smaller and cheaper and empty it out periodically?”
They were completely astonished at this question. How could they empty a latrine pit by hand? If they did so they wouldn’t be able to go to the temple, they wouldn’t be able to perform their rituals, they would be completely ostracized from their society. That’s why they wanted to build a pit this big.
And this household isn’t unique in feeling that way. In fact, many households in rural India feel the same way. While the WHO recommends pits of about 50 cubic feet in size, what we found in a SQUAT survey is that people tend to build pits that are five times the recommended WHO pit size.
And when we asked households what they would ideally like to build, they told us that they wanted to build pits that were 20 times that size. And you can imagine pits this large are quite expensive to build, so latrines that people use in India are much more expensive than the kinds of latrines that are commonly used in most other developing countries in the world.
So what’s the big deal with emptying a pit latrine?
I mean in pretty much most other countries in the world while emptying a pit latrine by hand isn’t the most fun thing to do, people still do it. But here in India handling feces carries a stigma. India is unique from other developing countries in the world because of its history of caste.
I’m sure most of you in this room know what caste you are. While the influence of caste is slowly declining in India, most people in India are still very conscious of it. And unfortunately, most people still think that higher caste people are purer than lower caste people.
Caste has a lot to do with sanitation because people from the lowest caste have been historically responsible for doing manual scavenging or the daily cleaning of feces from dry toilets by hand. We heard a lot about manual scavenging earlier this morning from Mr. Shaikh.
People from the lowest caste are considered permanently polluted. And because caste is still so important in Indian society even today, people from the lowest caste are often very socially marginalized and oppressed.
People from higher castes try to often avoid contact with from people from lower castes and their work because they believe if they come into contact with them, they will also become polluted. So this has a lot to do with latrine use in India because people associate emptying a pit latrine with manual scavenging.
What that means is that people from middle and upper castes would find it inconceivable to empty a pit latrine by hand themselves. At the same time, people from lower castes tend to avoid doing such work understandably, because it’s associated with their past and continuing oppression.
So the market for pit emptying in India has completely broken down. And that’s why people want huge pits. So while many rural Indians think of this when they think of using a latrine, many people think open defecation looks like this.
So I visited retired army officer in Haryana last year. And he had a big family. His four sons and their wives, and children, all lived with him. This family had a latrine. And it had a very large pit. They had probably spent 60,000 rupees or a thousand dollars on building this latrine. Only the children used this latrine. Everyone else in the family went in the open, even the young daughters-in-law.
So I asked this retired army officer, “Why do you go in the open instead of using your very nice latrine that you have right here at home?”
And he told me that going in the open allows him to exercise his body. It allows him to get the impurities out. And in fact, if he used a latrine he probably wouldn’t live as long. That’s why people in cities only live to 60 or 70 years, while people in villages live for 100 years. So this gentleman thought that defecating in the open was actually better for health than using a latrine.
And what we found in a SQUAT survey is that many households feel that way. In fact, most people who defecate in the open that we talked to in our SQUAT survey thought that going in the open was just as good for child health as using a latrine.
But let’s remember here. Even though we may imagine this beautiful field when we think of defecating in the open, going in the open is really bad for child health and kills hundreds of thousands of children each year in India.
So who’s working on this issue?
We heard just earlier about Gram Vikas. And fortunately, we also don’t have to prove to the government that sanitation is a worthy topic to be working on. In fact, the government has been building latrines in India for the past 15 years now.
But many of these latrines are the kinds of latrines that the WHO promotes. So it’s really no wonder that many of them end up looking like this. They are used for storerooms. They are left to become dilapidated.
So if constructing toilets isn’t going to work, what can we do?
What can the government do? What can you and I do? You know, I get this question all the time and I really wished that I had a good answer.