Skip to content
Home » On Purpose Podcast: w/ Mel Robbins on People Pleasing and Self-Criticism (Transcript)

On Purpose Podcast: w/ Mel Robbins on People Pleasing and Self-Criticism (Transcript)

Here is the full transcript of American author Mel Robbins’ interview on On Purpose Podcast with host Jay Shetty, January 14, 2026.

In this powerful live taping of the Jay Shetty Podcast, bestselling author Mel Robbins joins Jay to deconstruct the “shocking lie” of self-improvement and reveal why people-pleasing is actually a sophisticated form of manipulation. Robbins offers a transformative masterclass on silencing your inner critic, explaining how modern technology has biologically rewired us to judge ourselves at unsustainable rates.

The conversation dives deep into the “Let Them” theory for handling toxic relationships, the secret to turning jealousy into a strategic roadmap for success, and why you must stop waiting for an “idealized version” of yourself to start living. From personal stories of overcoming $800,000 in debt to the boring “reps” required to build a business, Robbins provides an unfiltered guide to authentic self-acceptance in early 2026.

Introduction

JAY SHETTY: I’m so excited to be here tonight at the Wang Theatre in Boston with one of my dearest, dearest friends. Truly. And I want to dive straight in, Mel, because you’ve got so much insight, so much wisdom on this that I’ve been fortunate enough to benefit from in our friendship.

But I want to start by asking you, what do you think people are most worried about when it comes to what others think about them?

MEL ROBBINS: Well, I brought notes because I know Jay asks very tough questions. I think that the thing that we’re most worried about is just that people aren’t going to like you, that they’re going to misunderstand you. That’s the thing that we’re the most worried about.

Because if you didn’t care whether or not people liked you, if you didn’t care about whether or not people misunderstood you or your intentions, you would just go about your life however the heck you wanted to, right?

And so, truly, if you stop and think, think about one person in your life, that’s the person whose opinion you worry about the most. Imagine if you could go about your life and not care if they like you or not. Not care if they don’t understand you or not.

And sometimes people be like, well, it’s my boss. Okay? There’s a lot of bosses out there. If the one that you’re working for doesn’t like you, there’s nothing you can do about it. But you can always leave the job.

And so I think that is what’s at the heart of it. That we are so desperate to be liked and understood and loved by others that we live in fear that it’s not going to happen. And in doing so, we basically live a life where we don’t really like ourselves.

JAY SHETTY: So well said. So well said. I mean, I think what you’re getting at there is so powerful because it’s almost like we don’t even know what we’re capable of, what we’re worthy of, what we’re able to do. Because we’ve constantly lived with that inner critic inside of us.

There’s the outer critic and the inner critic. Tell me about how we can learn to quiet that inner critic. Because sometimes it is your boss, sometimes it is your partner, sometimes it is your mom, but there’s that inner critic inside of you that’s stifling you even more.

MEL ROBBINS: Okay, I got to ask you a question first. Should I look at you or everybody out here? I don’t know where to look, because normally when Jay and I are talking and recording a podcast, we don’t see you guys. So it’s so cool to have you here, for real. Thank you for showing up.

JAY SHETTY: And I think we can look at them. I want to be with all of you.

Why Self-Criticism Has Skyrocketed in the Modern Age

MEL ROBBINS: Okay, great. Because I feel a little distracted, I’m ignoring you while I’m trying to look at Jay. And I want you to like me, for God’s sakes. Even though we’re going to talk about how we have to stop worrying about that.

Okay, so the question is about self-criticism. So there’s a lot to unpack here. And the first thing to understand is that there are two factors that truly amp up self-criticism. This is not from me. This is from some of the same experts that you have brought on to On Purpose.

The more stressed out that you are, the more the self-criticism dials up. There’s some relationship between you being in kind of fight or flight and your inability to be kinder and more present and compassionate with yourself. So that’s number one. If you’re experiencing an uptick right now because you feel stressed and overwhelmed, that’s to be expected.

Second thing, and this is going to blow your f*ing mind. Okay. Self-criticism. This is crazy. Okay, I’m going to try to unpack this because I literally just talked to a psychiatrist today at Harvard Medical School who does all this research on body image, and everybody is critical of themselves.

Self-criticism has really gone through the roof because check this out. We were never supposed to see ourselves. No, no, no, no, no. Really? Really. Hang with me for a minute here.

JAY SHETTY: Yeah.

MEL ROBBINS: Let’s just go back one or two human beings. Mirrors back then had all that acid stuff on it, so you couldn’t even see yourself. There were no glass buildings, so you didn’t see your reflection. If you saw yourself, it was in the Charles River, and it was kind of moving.

And so we are not neurologically, physiologically, emotionally designed to actually see ourselves. And we are designed, Jay, to connect with other people.

And so if you’re looking at other people, in a nanosecond, your brain immediately goes into this judgy mode because you’re judging. Okay, is this a person whose energy I vibe with and I kind of want to connect with this person? Or is this a person whose energy’s off, so I kind of want to move away from them?