Skip to content
Home » On Purpose Podcast: w/ Sabrina Zohar on Modern Dating (Transcript)

On Purpose Podcast: w/ Sabrina Zohar on Modern Dating (Transcript)

Editor’s Notes: In this episode of the Jay Shetty Podcast, Jay sits down with relationship expert Sabrina Zohar to break down the complexities of modern dating and the importance of intentionality. They explore why “effort equals interest” and how to navigate the confusion of digital communication by focusing on how a person actually makes you feel secure and seen. By shifting the focus from external validation back to yourself, this conversation provides a roadmap for setting healthy boundaries and finding a partner who truly aligns with your values. (Feb 9, 2026)

TRANSCRIPT:

The Modern Dating Dilemma: They Love Me, They Love Me Not

JAY SHETTY: I think the challenge today, or at least what I feel people struggling with, is almost like the old challenge of sitting there with a flower and going, “they love me, they love me not. They love me, they love me not.” And I don’t know when that was invented, but I feel like we’re ruminating, we’re overthinking, we’re procrastinating. How do you know if someone’s actually into you?

SABRINA ZOHAR: It’s so funny. Thank you for reminding me about the flower. Because as you said, I was like, oh, my childhood. I think what we’re really looking for, for me, I’m big on “effort equals interest.” And I think we’re getting in a time where that effort is starting to get muddied. We’re looking at it as, are they texting me every day? Are they contacting me? And we’re looking at these dopamine hits as opposed to actually connecting with people.

And so I think, for me, are you feeling safe, seen and secure with this person? Now, that might not happen after one date, but is this somebody that is reciprocal? Are they intentional? Are they consistent? Are they showing up for you? And that doesn’t just mean that they don’t text you for a day, but are they making plans? Are they actually progressing the relationship?

And I think for me, I’ll be honest, I have ADHD, so my cadence, my speech, I’m totally different, the way that my brain works. So I might show up differently and be super keen on somebody, whereas my partner is super avoidant, and he’s not into the texting. And his way of showing up is, “I’m going to spend time with you.”

And so I think it’s really important when we’re actually trying to assess if somebody likes you. I want to see, one, how does your nervous system feel? Are we constantly in this hyper, hypoarousal, hyperarousal? Are we high? Are we low? But I really think it goes back to the old school way of doing it. Can you have an open conversation with them? And at the end of the day, can you just ask them, “Hey, how are you feeling about this? And what are your intentions with where we’re going?”

I know it sounds like, oh, we all want a trick, and we all want something that we can look at. But I found really, most people are pretty apt to having a conversation if we approach it in the right way.

Why We Chase People Who Don’t Want Us

JAY SHETTY: Yeah. And I think you’re right. I think the challenge is that a lot of us still believe that love has to be earned and love has to be won. And so we love the idea of chasing and pursuing someone. And they become more attractive the more they avoid us and they become more exciting, the more elusive they are.

And them not messaging back for three days almost makes us think, they must be really busy and cool and interesting. And so I’ve really got to work harder, but only for us to feel let down, because all of those were just signs that “I’m not into you.”

So why is it that we chase people who are disinterested or showing disconnect, not doing all the things you just said? They’re not consistent. They don’t make you feel safe. They actually make you feel insecure because you’re constantly wondering whether they like you or not. Why do we keep chasing them and what should we do instead?

SABRINA ZOHAR: The number one question I ask is if you’re chasing somebody, if you’re going into the ruminating and the spiraling, I want you to check in with, how old do you feel? And where did I learn this from? Because those are the two questions, two things in general that changed my life.

Now, why do we do it? It’s interesting because when we ask why questions, and not that we’re not going to answer it, but ourselves, “Why don’t they like me? Why don’t they? Why aren’t they into me?” That’s intellectualizing. And when we’re intellectualizing, that’s our way of saying, if I can understand it intellectually, I don’t have to feel it.

And for a lot of us, at least me, I grew up in a very chaotic household. I grew up with no safety, really. There wasn’t a presence of joy or love. And so for me, it felt familiar. My nervous system understands, oh, you’re not into me, similar to my dad. Then let me make you. Let me earn it.

And then there’s the term repetition compulsion. Have you heard of it?

JAY SHETTY: No, I’ve not, actually.

SABRINA ZOHAR: Yeah, so repetition compulsion is a Freudian term. And essentially what it means is you’re going to date the parts of you that haven’t been healed.

JAY SHETTY: Say that again. That’s so good.

Repetition Compulsion: Dating Your Unhealed Parts

SABRINA ZOHAR: Yeah. So repetition compulsion means you’re going to date the parts of you that haven’t been healed. So for me, I had a narcissistic father. Every man I dated was incredibly narcissistic. Why? Because my nervous system’s homeostasis was, “you need to earn it. You’re not enough. There’s something wrong with you.”

That gets wired into us before words can even be said out of our mouths. That is wired in based on how your caregivers attuned to your needs, how are they showing up for you?