Skip to content
Home » Alastair Crooke: Israel LOSING, Charlie Kirk Truth BLOWS UP on Netanyahu (Transcript)

Alastair Crooke: Israel LOSING, Charlie Kirk Truth BLOWS UP on Netanyahu (Transcript)

Read the full transcript of Danny Haiphong Show titled “Alastair Crooke: Israel LOSING, Charlie Kirk Truth BLOWS UP on Netanyahu” with guests Alastair Crooke, Scott Ritter, Larry C. Johnson, and Gerald Celente, September 17, 2025.

Introduction

DANNY HAIPHONG: Good morning everyone, welcome back to the show. It’s your host Danny Haiphong and we have a big show today. So be sure to hit that like button as you come on that helps boost the stream in YouTube’s algorithm.

Now Israel is looking more and more like an out-of-control and desperate regime by the day as its brutal so-called offensive in Gaza is receiving condemnation far and wide, even by a new UN Commission report on the occupied territories, claiming that this is a genocide, stating firmly that this is a genocide. Its humiliating attack on Hamas negotiators in Qatar has only worsened widespread publication and speculation in the US and West about Israel’s possible involvement in the Charlie Kirk assassination.

Now as the situation deteriorates, Netanyahu is visibly showing signs of cracking. The word isolation is coming up more and more in Israeli circles, including by Netanyahu himself.

Guest Introduction

To discuss all of this and much more, I have with me, friend of the show, our first guest today, Alastair Crooke, former British diplomat, geopolitical commentator, analyst, and author. He is the host and curator of Conflicts Form Substance, which is in the video description below that you can catch after the show.

DANNY HAIPHONG: Alastair, good to see you.

ALASTAIR CROOKE: Hi, how are you? I’m good, I’m good.

DANNY HAIPHONG: Great to be back with you, Alastair.

The Charlie Kirk Situation and Republican Division

DANNY HAIPHONG: So yes, my first question to you, given your wealth of experience as a diplomat in this region in particular, now of course there have been many reports now, lots of damning journalism including by Max Blumenthal himself on the Charlie Kirk situation implicating Israel, including harsh meetings from Bill Ackman, huge Israeli lobbyist based in the United States, multi-billionaire. But the situation has massive geopolitical implications, Alastair, that I’d like you to get into given that what we are seeing, it appears, is this case of Charlie Kirk is reflecting something much bigger given the widespread speculation and now investigations leading to damning possible points of inquiry now. So what’s your reaction to this given your following and analysis of the region and your experience to doing diplomacy because Israel has also had many problems of late in this arena?

ALASTAIR CROOKE: Well, first of all, it comes to a background. There was the National Conservative Conference held very recently in the United States of conservatives. They are quite a divided group at the moment, and they became more divided at this meeting, and they divided sharply along the lines of those that support Israel and complained bitterly about those that thought you could be, if you like, America first and not support Israel.

And then a very vociferous group, I mean a very striking language coming out from the editor of the American Conservative saying “what the hell do you mean? We are… Why should support of Israel be part of an America First agenda.” And so there was already a fracture, quite a big fissure opening up in the Republican side.

And you had others and there were attacks made on those who supported it, Tucker Carlson and other Steve Bannon who were there. And although we don’t still have much of the details of what actually happened with this killing, I mean surprisingly after so long, it remains an enigma. An enigma wrapped in a riddle. It gets more bizarre as it goes on. So, you know, it’s difficult to be categorical about this.

But the schism that I said was already shaping up among the Republican conservatives was seemingly reflected with also Charlie Kirk and particularly his supporters. Charlie Kirk and his particularly his supporters and so that of course has been the center of attention.

Now whether there is any connection with his killing to this schism in the Conservative Party or not, we don’t know. There’s no telling exactly, but we do know there was tension building up. And we’ve seen reports and we’ve had reports from people like Max Blumenthal and others that there was a big row about his seemingly drift away from support for Israel.

And others say that isn’t necessarily so. And then important sort of younger members of the MAGA group like Nick Fuentes has been raising lots of questions about why we don’t have some details, why the case is so obscured and demanding that they should be put forward. And there’s a lot of anger and there’s a lot of polarization taking place. Real anger on both sides of it from, if you like, the liberal world but also from the Conservatives.

The Genie is Out of the Bottle

And I think what it is going to do is two things. One is, whatever the circumstances, whatever transpires about this killing of Charlie Kirk, whatever comes out from it, nonetheless it has opened out in a huge way this question of is it America first or Israeli first, Israel first. And whether that’s connected or not is not material. What is material is that this debate has really come to the fore. As much as because of commentators who have produced more and more, if you like, background to events.

So even if it transpires to produce nothing very much, and that unfortunately is the history of many of the things that you think some evidence or some information or some new facts are going to materialize, maybe they’re not. But nonetheless, this is changing. And it’s no wonder that some Israelis might have been very worried about this, because these younger Americans have wide support on the ground. And they are also people who come from a background of tradition and of church and have strong feelings about this.