Skip to content
Home » Max Blumenthal: Charlie Kirk and Zionist Billionaires (Transcript)

Max Blumenthal: Charlie Kirk and Zionist Billionaires (Transcript)

Read the full transcript of journalist and author Max Blumenthal’s interview on Judging Freedom with host Judge Napolitano on “Charlie Kirk and Zionist Billionaires”, October 6, 2025.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: Judge Andrew Napolitano here for Judging Freedom. Today is Monday, October 6, 2025. Max Blumenthal joins us now. Max, a friend, a pleasure, my dear friend. Thank you for joining us.

I want to explore the behavior of certain American billionaires, particularly the Ellisons who soon will own CBS, Paramount and TikTok. But before we get there, why do you think Trump told Netanyahu to stop bombing in Gaza and why is the bombing continuing?

Trump’s Ceasefire Call and Netanyahu’s Defiance

MAX BLUMENTHAL: Well, Trump told him to stop bombing because he thought he had a deal with Hamas. I mean, J.D. Vance, the Vice President, actually published Hamas accepting some version of Trump’s 21-point plan. The Trump Truth Social account published a photograph of Israelis protesting in support of a ceasefire to return their captive family members still in Gaza. So it seemed sincere.

Leaving aside the neocolonial nature of Trump’s plan, which is actually a pacification plan and not a peace plan, it seemed clear Trump wanted it to end. He wanted to be the head of a Gaza peace authority. Tony Blair was to come in as the head of the Gaza International Transitional Authority.

And Benjamin Netanyahu had other ideas, continued the bombing and slaughtered, I think about 60 people yesterday and wounded close to 160. The bombing continues. Two days ago, Israel deliberately targeted with a US warplane and a US missile a center for the blind run by UNRWA in central Gaza City.

Netanyahu is under sustained pressure from the fanatics in his coalition who comprise the heart of his coalition: Bezalel Smotrich, Itamar Ben-Gvir, lesser known figures like Orit Strock who say the so-called hostages are actually an impediment to total victory. And total victory consists of the destruction of northern Gaza, the Judaization of northern Gaza through new settlements and the expulsion of the population through ethnic cleansing into the Sinai Peninsula. That’s their agenda.

And if Netanyahu does otherwise, they could just blow up his entire coalition and send him back to court after he loses immunity. So Netanyahu has kept the bombing going. He’s gone before the Israeli public in Hebrew and said we actually have no plan to withdraw. And he stated explicitly yesterday that troops will remain, occupation soldiers will remain deep inside Gaza throughout the duration of this supposed peace plan.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: Well, why would Gaza accept such a thing? Why would Gaza surrender the hostages? Why would Gaza throw down their arms in the face of no deal at all?

Why Hamas Won’t Disarm

MAX BLUMENTHAL: Yeah, they’re not going to. Because Hamas understands if they give up their weapons, Gaza will not—the Israeli talking point of them giving up their weapons and surrendering and then Gaza returning to peace is just that. And everything the Israelis say is deceptive.

Look at the West Bank, where the Palestinian Authority has not only given up weapons, they’ve turned their weapons on fellow Palestinians on behalf of Israel. Go into any Palestinian refugee camp in any major Palestinian city, and by day the Palestinian Authority arrests Palestinians and by night the Israeli military raids and they coordinate.

And the West Bank is now not just cantonized, but it is on the verge of being annexed. It has been turned into a giant prison. Palestinians can’t travel from one city to another because of the amount of settler terror and military terror. And so Gaza will face that as well.

It was Hamas that expelled or pushed the Israeli military and Israeli settlers out after the second intifada and allowed people in Gaza to travel up and down their tiny little open-air prison freely for the first time. So they’re not going to give up weapons for the same reason Hezbollah won’t.

Hezbollah’s major accomplishment has been defending Lebanon against an Israeli occupation, forcing Israel to leave in 2000 and preventing Israel from marching to Beirut as it did in the early 1980s. So they’re facing pressure to put down their weapons. None of these groups will put down their weapons, but they will agree to a very one-sided agreement just to end the violence.

And you know, it’s a fact that Hamas is facing pressure from the civilian population of Gaza, which has suffered so much. But how can they negotiate when Israel is demonstrating the real power dynamic between itself and Washington? That, as Tucker Carlson said last week, Netanyahu is running around the region bragging that he has Trump under his thumb.

And by bombing Gaza after Trump says to stop, he is reinforcing that dynamic and illustrating everything Tucker Carlson said to be clearly true. The only way to stop Israel is through force, and Trump is unable to apply it.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: How did Netanyahu react, if you know, to Trump’s twice stated command that the Israelis will never annex the West Bank, he won’t let it happen?

The Gradual Annexation Strategy

MAX BLUMENTHAL: Well, they can annex it gradually and not formally. I mean, it also doesn’t serve Netanyahu’s interest to formally annex the West Bank. That’s something the settlers want. There’s ideological and religious messianic reasons for them to do it.

But for Netanyahu, politically it doesn’t serve him well to formally make the West Bank part of Israel, even though Israel doesn’t respect international law. It would mean under the Geneva Conventions they have an obligation to care for the population, to provide them with postal services, electricity. It would eliminate the Palestinian Authority, which would create a security vacuum which would lead to massive militancy. It just doesn’t serve him well.

He likes to keep the—it’s for the same reason that Israel, under successive prime ministers, including Netanyahu, insisted that they did not occupy the Gaza Strip, that they actually withdrew in 2005, 2006, even though they actually controlled the perimeters, the skies, the sea.