Skip to content
Home » Col. Douglas Macgregor: Gaza a Sideshow; Iran the Main Event (Transcript)

Col. Douglas Macgregor: Gaza a Sideshow; Iran the Main Event (Transcript)

Read the full transcript of consultant, and political commentator Col. Douglas Macgregor’s interview on Judging Freedom Podcast with host Judge Napolitano on “Gaza a Sideshow; Iran the Main Event”, October 13, 2025.

Opening Remarks and Sponsor Message

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: Hi, everyone. Judge Andrew Napolitano here for Judging Freedom. Today is Monday, October 13, 2025. Colonel Douglas Macgregor will be with us in a moment on Gaza and Iran. Is peace in one related to war in the other?

Colonel Macgregor, thank you for coming on the show today. And I know it’s not your usual time or date, and I truly appreciate your accommodating my schedule. What are your thoughts, Colonel, on the events in Israel today?

Initial Assessment of the Gaza Ceasefire

COL. DOUGLAS MACGREGOR: I must say that probably more than many, I’m skeptical of all of it. Obviously, everybody hopes for an end to the tragedy in Gaza and an end to this Israel versus the whole Islamic world. But I just am unconvinced that we’re going to get much beyond this initial phase of returning hostages, the remaining living hostages that Hamas has along with remains. And of course, I think it’s roughly 1,200 Palestinian prisoners that are held by the Israelis.

Beyond that, I just have very, very little confidence that this kind of peace can be sustained. And I still think that the war with Iran looms over the horizon.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: What undermines your confidence? Is it the right wing pressure from within his government on Prime Minister Netanyahu? Is it his failure to have defeated Hamas? Is it his recognition of the destruction he’s caused to Israeli society that in his own way of thinking, can only be resolved with more, can only be united with more war?

Trump’s Role and Donor Influence

COL. DOUGLAS MACGREGOR: You know, I suppose it could be all of those factors. I also think this is something that President Trump both wanted and felt that he needed. President Trump has been frustrated because he hasn’t been able to publicly take credit for some sort of peace arrangement in the Middle East. I think he very much wants a settlement. Having said that, he now has the optics of a settlement, and frankly, for him, that may be enough. He’s very focused on optics, on appearances.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: Right.

COL. DOUGLAS MACGREGOR: You saw him on the stage in front of the giant American flag, a la George Patton in the movie. I think he’s very delighted with that. But I would point out that in the final analysis, he is not a completely free agent. I think he’s still a prisoner of his donors. And his wealthiest and most important donors are those associated with Israel and its interests. I think they wanted something, but I don’t think they’ve given up on the Greater Israel project at all. So I think this is a pause. How long will it last is anybody’s guess.

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: Well, the Israelis are committed, A, to Greater Israel and B, to eradicating the Palestinians from the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. I mean, that’s in their genetic makeup, or at least this government has committed them to that.

COL. DOUGLAS MACGREGOR: I think the Israeli population agrees with you, Judge. I think at least 80% of them are absolutely supportive of those goals. So this again looks like a pause to me, as opposed to some sort of permanent outcome.

The Likelihood of Resumed Hostilities

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: What happens when the IDF resumes bombing Gaza, which could happen next week?

COL. DOUGLAS MACGREGOR: Yeah. My impression is that once all the hostages are returned, there will probably be some small period of pacification or something resembling peace, but then the shooting will resume. And there are so many other actors involved in this thing right now. The Israelis have some proxy forces that are Arabs, supposedly with some connection back to Syria and ISIS. Then you still have Hamas that remains active and supportive. I just don’t see how this mix of volatile participants can avoid colliding with each other.

So I think you’re right. I think at some point the bombing will resume. Now, the question is, what happens with Iran? And I know that certainly Prime Minister Netanyahu was able to talk briefly on the phone with President Putin and supposedly express the view that Israel doesn’t want a war with Iran. Well, I think the Iranians have heard that before. I’m not sure that’s going to change anybody’s readiness to fight in Iran.

So I’m still, I’m just skeptical by nature of the whole business. This has been tried before. It doesn’t work.

Trump’s Controversial Statements About Netanyahu

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: I want to ask you about Iran in a minute, but before we do, I want your comments on some of the more extreme things the President said today. I wonder if he thinks that Netanyahu is guilty of crimes and for that reason needs a pardon. Chris, number 12.

VIDEO CLIP BEGINS:

PRESIDENT TRUMP: Okay, I have an idea, Mr. President. Why don’t you give him a pardon? By the way, that was not in the speech, as you probably know, but I happen to like this gentleman right over here, and it just seems to make so much sense, you know, whether we like it or not. This has been one of the greatest wartime presidents. This has been one of the greatest wartime presidents. And cigars and champagne. Who the hell cares about…

VIDEO CLIP ENDS:

JUDGE NAPOLITANO: First of all, he’s referring to the Prime Minister of Israel as the president. Secondly, to say that he is engaged in behavior that can be characterized as great is truly demented, in my view, in light of what Netanyahu has done. He has caused the entire world to question the moral basis of the Zionist experiment.

COL.