Skip to content
Home » TRANSCRIPT: The Chosen’s Jonathan Roumie on The Tucker Carlson Show

TRANSCRIPT: The Chosen’s Jonathan Roumie on The Tucker Carlson Show

Read the full transcript of a conversation between Tucker Carlson and The Chosen’s Jonathan Roumie on the Tucker Carlson Show episode titled “The Chosen’s Jonathan Roumie: Answering God’s Call & Christian Resilience in the Face of Persecution”, premiered on March 5, 2025.

Listen to the audio version here:

TRANSCRIPT:

The Unexpected Call to Play Jesus

TUCKER CARLSON: You’re an actor. You’re looking for work. Your agent or somebody calls you and says, we’d like you to play Jesus. What’s that like?

JONATHAN ROUMIE: It was an answered prayer. The person who made that call was a friend and a colleague by that point, a guy by the name of Dallas Jenkins who created The Chosen. I had played Jesus for him for his church’s Good Friday service in these little vignettes three times over the course of four years between 2014 and 2017.

TUCKER CARLSON: Just literally in a church?

JONATHAN ROUMIE: In a church. So we’d go and shoot out on a farm, these vignettes. His church has a little studio, and we would film mostly on location. We would create these little films that would be in the spirit of Good Friday or illustrate a particular gospel passage or scripture scene, in line with the theme of the service for that year.

The First Time Playing Jesus

The first time I played Jesus in one of those short films was the crucifixion. I was in it for five minutes. The film itself is called “The Two Thieves.” You can actually find it, I think, on Amazon still. It was a “what if” story about the two thieves crucified on either side of Christ. Like, who were they? How did they get there?

In one of the gospels, in one paragraph, it goes from him being mocked and reviled even by the thieves next to him to all of a sudden, the penitent thief, as he’s referred to, gives his life basically to Jesus in that moment, saying, “Lord, remember me when you come into your kingdom.” And Jesus says, “Truly, today, you will be with me in paradise.” It’s like the first confession on the cross, and he grants him access to the kingdom.

Dallas tries to answer the question of how you go from being one of the mockers, revilers to this sudden conversion on the cross in the course of this 25-minute film.

I actually read for the penitent thief because he’s got this fantastic narrative arc. I thought I’d had a great audition. It was in LA at the time. I knew it was an opportunity to get paid a nominal stipend for some work in another city, in this case, suburban Chicago. I thought, “I would audition for this short film. I don’t care if it’s for a church. It’s a great story. The script is great.”

From Supporting Role to Lead

So I go and I auditioned. I had a great audition. I’m like, “I think I nailed it.” Couple days later, I get a callback to come back in, but this time to read for Jesus. And I thought to myself, “Oh, man. I didn’t get the first role.” And then I looked again at the script. I’m like, “Jesus got, like, five lines in the whole thing.”

But I had happened to have played Jesus six months prior for another completely independent project up in Washington State. They were at a studio for this Catholic company called Saint Luke Productions about a saint in the early twentieth century named Saint Faustina who was considered a mystic. She had these visions. She wrote an entire diary that was sort of dictated to her by Christ himself in these visions. And so I played Jesus in the vision aspect of that story.

Fast forward six months later, I get this audition for “The Two Thieves.” I didn’t get the penitent thief. I go and I audition for Jesus because I’m like, “You know what? I enjoyed playing Jesus six months ago. This would be cool if I got anything.” It’d be cool because I wasn’t working steadily or consistently.

And the way Dallas tells the story, about ten seconds into the audition, he’s like, “That’s Jesus. That’s my Jesus for this show.”

The Path to The Chosen

So we did that film, and it was screened. He brought me back to view it, like, a month later at the Good Friday service with his church, about seven services. It was fifteen thousand people who saw this thing in a matter of a day and a half. And it was remarkably well received. It was so beautiful, and it was essentially the foundational bones of the concept of The Chosen.

It’s this sort of Ignatian spirituality, this Ignatian insight into the gospels, which is basically you put yourself in the gospel. You ask yourself a series of questions, and that’s how you meditate on the gospels through this form of spirituality.

We did it again the following year for a different kind of scene, and then we skipped a year. And then spring of 2017, I did one more film with him for his church. And then it was in probably the summer of 2018 where he called me and said, “Hey. Want to put the sandals back on? I think we’re going to do four episodes of a crowdfunded TV show. Probably not going to go anywhere, but it’d be some consistent work.” And I jumped at the chance.

I thought, okay. I had now played Jesus for him a few times. I was getting really comfortable with the role. I was also pulled in during that time between, like, 2016 and 2019, I started doing these passion plays, being involved in these passion plays that a friend of mine was directing. And then I helped codirect, and then I co-wrote a version of the passion that we would put on for our church.

And so for whatever reason, God was putting me in these situations, in these stories about Jesus so often in such a relatively short period of time.